Thank you for all of the help, gentleman! Unfortunately, I am still undecided.

Here are the top contenders in no particular order:

1) Blackhawk/Bisley Hunter .44
2) SRH .44
3) 10.5" Blackhawk .44
4) BFR .454

Kinda of looks the same, doesn't it.

I have had the opportunity to handle all four of the guns, and I have owned #1 and #2. The two best feeling in the hand were #2 and #4, the bisley and blackhawk grips just feel really, really small and don't fit my hand all that well. I actually liked how the BFR fit my hand.

If I could find one, my first choice would be a Magnaport Stalker w/ a Pachmayr grip...kind of like this one:



I have been lusting over one since I read "Hunting for Handgunners" as an impressionable teenager. That Gary is one lucky dude!