I went back and measured the groups. The federal 158 gr put three shots inside of 1". The BB 158 gr put three inside of 1 7/8". The Barnes group was wider but I am not sure what the group size really was because I was still sighting in when I was shooting them.

The BB group printed 1 1/2 inches above the Federal group.

What do you think? Which would you use?

When I shot these groups I was sitting in a folding chair and propping the gun on my leg with it crossed like I do when I hunt.