How many times are you going to post this? How many times are you going to ignore his clarifications on web sites? When someone on AR stated that the bear was not charging Phill stated that he knew when a bear charges and that this bear definitely charged.

Do I need to find that post and quote it as well?
Phill is not a professional writer and his words were such as some may take exception in the little short story about the incident. You are proving to be quite obtuse.