A thought not mentioned is weight of the handgun. You can cover a lot of ground cat hunting. Considering cats are not hard to kill, and any of your listed handguns will work fine. I would consider which one would pack the easiest.
Just My Two cents
Bob
That's one of the reasons I'm considering my .357, it's a 6" S&W 586, I have a Diamond D Guide's Choice Chest rig for it, nice setup!!
