I picked whitetails. I would have to go with my 480SRH. It's the only handgun I have that i would use to shoot a deer. I would rather use my bow. But that may be just because I have bowhunted since I was 7.
In WV, we only have a 2 week firearm buck season, 1 week doe season, and 1 week muzzleloader season. I really enjoy using my pistol when I draw a doe tag, but that usually is once every other year.