I own them both in 44 Mag and like them equally well. I have a 9.5ish inch SBH and a 7.5" SRH. I really like the scope mounting system on the SRH, and though I would use a scope but went back to a pair of Williams Firesights for now. If you consider the SBH hunter there is no difference in scope mounting. A variety of sight options are available for the SRH if you are like my and have bad eyes; SBH open sight options are pretty scant unless you are handy or know a gunsmith. I carry the SRH in camp, in the truck, and when there is a chance to get gored by something as the double action may have some added benefit in a "oh crap" situation. I think the single action handles better though, is better looking, and my version has a much better trigger than the SRH even after a spring kit and some minor work. Try them both though and see which one you prefer, and don't forget the standard redhawk, it may be an option in 44 Mag depending on your needs.