I had a 10" Max and I still have the 10" Herrett. In the 10" not enough difference to worry about. I kept the Herrett because of the two barrel's it was the most accurate; the Max gave me 2 1/2 @ 100 yards and the Herrett 1 1/2 - 2". Of course that was just my two barrels and is not a real test...your mileage may vary!

Bill in OR