Probably answered my own question already but, I like the S&W Trail Boss, the 3" .44 magnum. It looks quite packable and handy, and to me it has a certain "cool factor".
I have a 4" M29 I am considering cutting to 3" to basically have the Trail Boss, only in blue finish. I already am thinking this would be a waste of $$ as a 4" is really pretty packable, handy and easy to holster and shoot. As mentioned in post a day or so ago I will only shoot 240 gr. out of it, (as with my SBH). I just think the money could be better spent elsewhere. Any opinions one way or the other??

I've never found an inch of barrel to be difficult to carry. I would prefer the longer sight radius and higher velocity over a little bit shorter of a holster.

I would like a 3 uinch barrel, but I have a 4 inch barrel on my carry gun because if I wish to use it to hunt deer in Oklahoma regs require 4 inch minimum.

I would think it wouldnt cost much to cut it down but as was said to what purpose an inch shorter wouldnt accomplish anything to the good.

If you follow along on the Colt, S&W Forums and Gunbroker, you will find that the 3" revolvers are all carrying a very high cool factor, price and desirability right now. For the older models, it seems to be rarity of production. For the newer models, the trend seems to be a little easier for concealed carry, and the speed at which you can "skin" it.

I don't have any 3"ers, but I do have the almost 4ish, and a couple of large frame 2 and change. About the only time I see a difference is in concealed carry, with a high rise type holster. The 4 inch class can be a little harder on getting clearance to the front of the holster compared to the shorter. But even that can be mitigated by a holster that has a bit of swoop to the front. The shorter ones also ride a little better in the vehicle seat. And this is all with strongside carry.

I've got the bug for a 45acp revolver right now, and have decided 4 inch. As Hank noted, I might hunt with it, and 4 inch is common for hunting regs. And I know I can find a holster (or make one) that will make carrying and drawing a snap. If I could afford both, the 3" would be nifty for "those times". With the funds for only one, I feel a 4 has a touch more functionality for me.

Good luck with the decision, and stay out of those 3" revolver threads......;^)

Craig

Ever shoot a 3". Not friendly with full power stuff. If you load down may as well buy a .44 Sp. 4" is the way to go.