Why do I bite on the hard questions? Answer...Insomnia.
This is sort of like comparing apples to oranges to pears but I made them all into apples with mathmatics.
Here we go...
44 Rem Mag 3.5 lb gun Recoil Vel 16.5 FPS
200gr bullet- Recoil Enrgy 14.7 Ft Lbs
Apparent Felt Recoil. Moderate
S&W 460 XVR 5Lb gun Recoil Vel 17.4 FPS
200gr bullet- Recoil Enrgy 23.6 Ft Lbs
Apparent Felt Recoil. Vigorous**
375 JDJ 4.5 Lb gun Recoil Vel 25.9 FPS
210gr bullet- Recoil Enrgy 41.0 Ft Lbs
Apparent Felt Recoil. Severe
458 Lott*** 6LB gun Recoil Enrgy 102 Ft Lbs
500gr bullet- Apparent Felt Recoil. RUNUTZ
**This gun is equipped with a factory muzzle break and can expect a 35-40% reduction in felt recoil.
***Just for the Fun of it.
This data is based on Factory and handload reloading data using 200 and 210 gr jacketed bullets. Recoil was calculated by "Load from a Disk" External-Internal Ballistic Program. Gun weights were determined by approximate gun weights from my collection and the S&W website
Glad you didn't ask for Trajectory and Down Range Ballistics.