yeah, my panties aren't in a wad. i'm just stating my opinion of your opinion on a public forum where keyboard warriors battle. i think it was childish and whiny to comment negatively on a book that took hours upon hours and it just gets me a bit riled when someone posts a creation of theirs be it a gun/holster/book and someone gets negative. you don't like it, fine, but remember what yo mama taught ya. if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all. i've seen books/videos etc i didn't like everything in them but i keep my comments and critiques to myself. you should do the same.

I am having a hard time with the new book, just too similar to the other book, Big Bore Revolvers. A LOT of the SAME articles and photos. Just my opinion but if you are going to write another book at least write ANOTHER book. I can't read thru a complete chapter without seeing an article or picture from the first book.

And where do you see anything in my post that is negative?? There's nothing negative here, only an opinion. Now admit it, your panties ARE in a wad.

no my long johns are, i don't wear panties but i guess we transfer to others that which is familiar to us at home sometimes.
yes you said something negative, it was a negative opinion! which is ok, but i guess you should contribute in some way to this sporting endeavor if you're gonna complain. from what i've seen you haven't. nuff said, just my opinion.

I expressed an opinion just like you did, nothing negative. Even if it were negative if someone can't take negative opinions the internet is not the place to post anything you don't want commented on. I never said anything negative about Max' book, even he admits there is some overlapping coverage. Now it's time for you take your ball and go home.

nope, mine was just an opinion, why is it bothering you so bad that i didn't like your opinion. i can take a negative opinion, i also can respond to one as well. why is that such an issue for you since opinions are a free for all since it's the internet.

I got my copy last Friday,and i would like to make a couple of comments,the layout of this book is awesome, there is some re-hash, no big deal at all, I thought the pictures were very good,A good compilation of our sport, as far as I know there"s only 2/3 guys putting our handgun stuff out there, Whit is one of them, I have all 3 books , I thought this was the best one!

I finally will get home tomorrow where mine has been waiting for me for the past 2 weeks. Can't wait to dive into it.

LOL, "admit" makes it sound like I have something to be guilty about! I told the readership in the introduction chapter that I was repeating some pertinent edit.


Gentlemen, thank you for the kind words, they're much appreciated. As Mark Hampton earlier stated, writing a book is a daunting task, that drains a lot out of you. However hard we try to please everyone, it's not realistic. Hope you enjoy.

Pertaining to "repetitive content", speaking for myself only, I have read many books that I considered to be well above average more than a single read. Some fiction, some history, some sci-fi, and some non fiction including Max's Big Bore Revolvers, and the History of Ruger Revolvers. Reading a book more than once is surely repetitive, and speaks to the quality of the book. I suspect I am not the only one that has read some books more than once, and only books that are enjoyed the first time get more time. I'm looking forward to reading the new book when it arrives, and I may even read it twice, even if it does contain some of the same pictures and a few words I've alreardy read twice. Whitworth, thanks for taking the time to collect and log your own experiences into written form. I struggle myself to write up a good short story to post here about a deer I killed. I can only imagine the time/effort that goes into a full book.

IMO it would be next to impossible to write one book about big bore revolvers and yet another about hunting revolvers without sharing some content. The two topics are closely related. I applaud the effort, Max.

X2

nicely said Rod...........

I don't look at books like those written by Max, John Taffin, and others as simply a book like a novel. To me they are reference libraries to be read and studied many times. If I knew everything they know I wouldn't need to read anymore. I still look back to Gary's first two printed "magazines". They are very well done as are Max's books. Thank you gentlemen.

[quote=bowmag]I don't look at books like those written by Max, John Taffin, and others as simply a book like a novel. To me they are reference libraries to be read and studied many times. If I knew everything they know I wouldn't need to read anymore. I still look back to Gary's first two printed "magazines". They are very well done as are Max's books. Thank you gentlemen. [ /quote]

What he said!!!!,

I just finished reading Max's new book on Hunting Revolvers. I've been using the same .44 SB for years and wanting to get into a hunting handgun more modern. It definitely gave me a lot to think about. It will become a reference book for me I'm sure. One thing I found interesting in the book was in the chapter with the more famous handgun hunters in the rear of the book. It seemed as though they all used the 454. Not all but most. I also had not thought about the dot-sight. That really got me thinking. My eyes are not what they used to be. Anyway thanks for writing it. It really helped me go in the right direction.

Cessna, thank you for the kind words. Posts like yours make the overwhelming labor well with the effort. Thank you!

Red dots are a great alternative to open iron sites as they don't magnify. While relatively long shots can be taken with a red dot, I personally like the up close and personal aspect of handgun hunting and the red dot helps particularly as the eyes get older. Plus, they are great in low light!

Whitworth, I totally agree with the up close and personal
aspect of hunting. I've a gun cabinet full of scoped rifles, but have found myself hunting with my lever-actions more. I've only hunted deer and javalina and a few bears with the .44. And a mountain lion or two. I would like to hunt some African game and also some eastern deer. Thus the reason for a more modern handgun. I think it also boils down to just wanting a new revolver with a few modern twists. Anyway I really enjoyed the book, thanks for taking the time to write it. I don't know which way I'm going yet. More than likely a single-action with the red dot. I'll have to think about the caliber a bit. I have a lever-action rifle in 45LC and really enjoy it. I'd never considered it as a handgun cartridge until I read your book. I think I'd like the 454 just to have a big-bore. I will probably read the book again to help me.

No matter how many of these books you read I can assure you, you will always learn something, all of us do, no matter how much experience you have.
Eastern hunting is different than western hunting, African hunting is different than hunting safari style in Texas, the 44 magnum you refer to as old & not very modern compared to some of the newer hot rods, it all gets explained in these books by authors who have tried, failed & then succeeded over many years by getting out in the game fields & finding out what works. There's no easy way to get there.
Handgun hunting demands patience, practice, failure, more practice, experimenting, more practice, swapping ideas, more practice....you get the idea.
No one was born a successful handgun hunter, you earn you way into it. If optics are a necessity that red dot could be the answer, I've tried them twice & they weren't for me but I'm going to try one a third time because both previous times when they cost me a muley buck it was really the situation, not the dot sight that caused the problem. Most times I carry 2 sixguns, one sicking out of the top of my backpack, the second in a good (Barranti) shoulder or belt rig.
Read, re-reading & then practicing what you read in these books speeds up the learning curve & saves you much time & money from guys with years of experience.
Don't be offended to hunt high fence property, you have to gain experience somehow. Hunting one week a year for one deer is a hard way to learn. Get some experience under your belt & then move up the food chain. Some of us can hunt every day, others have to drive 2 hours just to find a tin can to tumble.
If you truly want to be a sixgunner study what you read, don't over gun, you can slow down a big gun!! And then get out there, don't talk about it, do it!!!!! I've always found there are 2 kinds of sixgunners, those that can & those that talk about it, which are you, challenge yourself.

Dick

Thanks sixshot, that's good advise. I remember in about 1963 when I shot my first game animal with a 44. It was looked on as some sort of stunt. Things have changed greatly in the years following. I really do want to try the red dot sighting system. It will be totally new for me. As I am a get as close as you can type hunter it just might work out fine for me. I remember my first trip to Africa in the late 60's. It was completely different than what I was used to. But reading about it today, it's totally different now than in the 60's. I tend to keep things forever that work for me. In reading books like Max's it makes me want to try something different.

NEVER HEARD OF THIS BOOK UNTIL NOW, JUST BOUGHT 1 ON EBAY, LOOKING FORWARD TO GETTING AND READING IT.

This is the reason I went to a fenced outfit (way back when) to take my first boar.... It sucked waiting one year just to make one shot....

45MAN, it really opened up some new things for me. I'd been hunting with the same old 44 for years and really found out how much it had changed. It's put a new excitement back into it for me. I tend to listen to someone whom I feel writes from experience. Max's writing seems to be from someone who has been there and done that. His conclusions make sense to me, and he makes his case for the various calibers well. I think you will enjoy the book like I did.

TRUTH!

I use them for testing purposes. Nothing more credible than putting bullet to flesh IMHO.

Yeah but its alot like africa. Very much so. Great practice and highly applicable. Ive been charged more in texas than africa!

TRUTH! Killing stuff with a sixgun is not an everyman skill.

Max,

Just finished RE-reading Hunting Revolvers (third time through). Believe it or not; but the text and photos were exactly the same as the first time I read it. However, every time I read and re-read a book, I find new information or a new way to consider the information presented. A most informative and enjoyable read, no matter how many times I read your book(s).
Excellent job, as usual! Keep up the work!

Doc

Good books should be savored ,read and re read. As Doc said something new pops up every time you re read a good book.

Thanks a bunch, Doc! I appreciate it!

This is so true. Maybe since reading a book you have acquired a new gun, tried a different load/bullet, have started hunting a different game or in a different method, etc. When reading the book again you may read something that you just scanned before since it didn't seem to affect you then. Now it clicks....

Just finished it this weekend while on vacation. Great Book.
Thanks Max

Bamabow

Thank you, sir!

When u consider layout, photos, information, and writing style i consider it the finest book of its type!

That's an enormous compliment, thank you!

I haven't finished it but so far so good. Very enjoyable. May finish it this weekend. Beautiful layout and photos!

IMHO, it is the finest book on handgun hunting extant. I remember how instantly impressed I was the first time I cracked it open. I'm probably biased but it is exceedingly well done!

Just got my American Hunter yesterday and saw where You (Max) had an article in it about handguns. Haven't read it yet, but congrats.

Bamabow

The American Hunter article is a good one. Lots of good info. Well done, Max.

Thanks guys, I appreciate it!

I very recently finished both Big Bore Revolvers and Hunting Revolvers. I think they are both magnificent and will be referring to them often. As a matter of fact, based on Max's writing, I decided to add a SRH in .480 Ruger to my collection of handguns. I bought from a member and can't wait to get it in my hands. I will now have a SBH Hunter in .44 Mag and a .480.