Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
XPB vs A Frame - 454 Casull - African Plains Game #205075 01/14/2020 8:40 PM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 522
Walkingthemup Offline OP
addict
OP Offline
addict
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 522
I'm in the planning stages for a African hunt which will target plains game up to and including Kudu, Nyala and Eland. I'm seeking advice specifically related to which projectile will be the better performer. The platform will be a 7.5 inch .454 Casull. Maximum shooting distance to 125.

Due to supply situation in my country, projectile choice will come down to either a 250 gr Barnes XPB or a 300 gr Swift A Frame. Normally I would go for the heavier projectile because of better penetration, however many claim the XPB has similar penetration to the heavier projectiles.

In my revolver the maximum velocity I've been able to get out of the XPB is 1700 fps. Acceptable accuracy at 25 with this load but haven't tested at longer range yet (you wouldn't believe how expensive these bullets are out here).

Haven't been able to acquire the A Frames yet as they will need to be a special order from the importer. (generally the importer only stocks A Frames in rifle calibres.)

Re: XPB vs A Frame - 454 Casull - African Plains Game [Re: Walkingthemup] #205077 01/14/2020 9:10 PM
Joined: Aug 2017
Posts: 1,821
45MAN Offline
Pooh-Bah
Offline
Pooh-Bah
Joined: Aug 2017
Posts: 1,821
I HAVE DONE 10 AFRICAN SAFARIS WHERE MY PRIMARY WEAPON WAS A FREEDOM ARMS 454 LOADED WITH 454 EQUIVALENT 45 COLT LOADS OR 454 LOADS. I USED A VARIETY OF BULLETS, BUT NONE OF THE 2 YOU ASK ABOUT, HOWEVER, IF I HAD TO CHOOSE BETWEEN THE 2 I WOULD CHOOSE THE SWIFT A-FRAME WITH THE BARNES XPB NOT EVEN A CLOSE SECOND. THE XPB's ARE LIGHT FOR LENGTH AND LIGHTER THAN THE SWIFTS. THEY MAY BE AN OK CHOICE ON DEER BUT PERSONALLY I WOULD NOT CHOOSE THEM FOR BIG PLAINS GAME, NOR FOR THE LONGER SHOTS YOU CONTEMPLATE.


"ADAPT OR DIE". I USE ALL CAPS, NOT BECAUSE I AM YELLING, BUT BECAUSE IT IS AN OLD HABIT FROM MY ARMY DAYS, PLUS IT IS EASIER TO TYPE AND READ.
Re: XPB vs A Frame - 454 Casull - African Plains Game [Re: 45MAN] #205081 01/15/2020 2:18 AM
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 1,642
BBwheelgunner Offline
Pooh-Bah
Offline
Pooh-Bah
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 1,642
Walkingthemup,

TradMark would be one of the more knowledgeable users of the Barnes XPB on this site from what I know.

Barnes did update their load data for this bullet and cartridge on their website if you haven't checked it out yet.

I like the XPB from the limited amount I have used it (killed one mule deer a few years back with it, see added picture)
But, If I were after Eland, I would feel more comfortable with the 300gr Swift. then you know you'd have it covered.

You are asking in the right place though, so much experience on this site!


Last edited by BBwheelgunner; 01/15/2020 2:19 AM.

"If you are going to go through all the trouble to put a hole in something, why not make it a big one?"
Re: XPB vs A Frame - 454 Casull - African Plains Game [Re: 45MAN] #205082 01/15/2020 3:07 AM
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 465
WiseGuy Offline
addict
Offline
addict
Joined: Dec 2012
Posts: 465
I have only used the XPB in my 454 and only for deer. I recovered one bullet from a doe that I shot at 152 yds. Entrance was on the high shoulder and bullet was recovered on the opposite side at the base of the neck just under the skin. Expansion was about as perfect as you could get. However with seeing the amount of penetration and recovering the bullet I would be very hesitant to use that bullet for larger plains game. IMO


Bigger ain't always better....according to who???
Re: XPB vs A Frame - 454 Casull - African Plains Game [Re: WiseGuy] #205088 01/15/2020 3:02 PM
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 1,048
wvhitman Offline
old hand
Offline
old hand
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 1,048
I've never shot any really big stuff with my .454 FA. Always used .475 and .500s. But, I've tested a lot of .454 bullets on deer. I always felt if a .454 bullet wouldn't completely penetrate a whitetail, then I wouldn't use it on larger game. I've dug several bullets from whitetails, but never a AFrame. That's what I'd use. The extra weight should help a little more with penetration.
Elands are big, tough animals. Dropped mine with one shot, but with a .375/.284 XP.
Kudus not so tough. Dropped 2 with 125/130 gr. 6.5/.284. Did wound my first one in 1985 at 250-300 with a .375 JDJ. Trailed him up. Did not look sick. Dropped him hard with a 310 gr. SSK lead in a RSB at 60 yds. Caliber and weight help a lot with big animals.

Re: XPB vs A Frame - 454 Casull - African Plains Game [Re: wvhitman] #205089 01/15/2020 3:45 PM
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 9,836
Whitworth Offline
Shootist
Offline
Shootist
Joined: Jan 2009
Posts: 9,836
I've used both in .454 on game. The XPB does a lot of internal damage and penetrates reasonably well. That said, I prefer the A-frame as it definitely penetrates deeper and does quite a bit of damage also. I used A-frames in .454 on a nyala and red lechwe and they performed admirably.


Max Prasac

Semper Fidelis

BIG IRON: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L6aXjMH5C30

Gun Digest TV's Modern Shooter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nGo-KMpXPpA&t=7s

Re: XPB vs A Frame - 454 Casull - African Plains Game [Re: Whitworth] #205113 01/16/2020 6:30 PM
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 9,715
jamesfromjersey Offline
Shootist
Offline
Shootist
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts: 9,715
between the two bullets you listed I would choose the Swift bullet without hesitation....


Life member-NRA-SCI
Member-HHI #2900-HHASA #067
Colt-Ruger-Freedom Arms-and S&W Collector Assoc.s
"I have more guns then I need but not as many as I want" "Handgun hunters HAVE to be good"
Re: XPB vs A Frame - 454 Casull - African Plains Game [Re: jamesfromjersey] #205138 01/18/2020 9:16 PM
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 522
Walkingthemup Offline OP
addict
OP Offline
addict
Joined: Oct 2005
Posts: 522
A big thanks for all the advice. Now to try and get the Swift distributor to import some A-Frames so I can start load development.


Moderated by  Chance Weldon, Gary, Gregg Richter 

Newest Members
Redhawk41, Striker243, Sxviper, RobbieD, IRONMAN
9668 Registered Users
Top Posters(30 Days)
Who's Online Now
0 registered members (), 66 guests, and 3 spiders.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.3