Should I be bumping the shoulder back ever so slightly?
i always use a full length die adjusted to my best ability to maintain shoulder position at all times.
if your case shoulder position is not correct(correct headspace), then that could possibly be causing your misfires. another option is the hammer spring, but i'd check headspace first.
ideally you want your case to fill the chamber + the amount of barrel to frame gap....minus a couple thousandths.
you can remove the barrel, use the chamber as the gauge, and determine if your case is going in too deep or sticking out too far. adjust the full length sizer accordingly.