Another vote for the Ruger Bisley. And yes it is better than a S&W. Start thumping heavy 45 Colt loads through both & see which chums first? I doubt you'd loosen a Ruger in your life time. If you care to spend more try a BFR or even FA's. They're great but the Ruger gives the most value & you can do what ever you want to it as you go along & form your own preferences. $115 for a top notch action job from Mag-Na-Port & you'll have a sweet shooter.