During cold weather I always feel like I do not control my FA .454 while using gloves; even when I take them off for shooting, my palm is dry and cold with minimal friction btwn palm and grip so I have to squeeze it more than I would like.
I made compromise by using Pro-Aim gloves. They are made from neoprene (so not warm enough) but tinny rubber lines at palm area always provide good grip. If it’s too cold I put some worm winter glove on left hand but keep Pro-Aim on my shooting hand