New member here, I was wondering if you guys could help me decide what load to use for whitetail this fall. I'm going to try and use my Blackhawk if I get a close shot. My shots will be inside 50 yards, preferably closer.

The two loads I'm deciding between are a 230 xtp at about 950 fps and a 300 xtp at about 800 fps. I'm using Accurate #5 (not the best powder for this but it's what I got) and can't find +P data for these two bullets, so I can't get them faster with #5.

What would be your choice? Thanks guys

-Hayden