If recoil and accuracy was an issue to a shooter in full power magnum loads, which caliber would be a better option for deer/antelope?

45 colt 250gr at 1K FPS
44 mag 240gr at 1K FPS
41 mag
357 mag
10mm

If my numbers are correct, in 45 colt the 300gr XTP looks better at 100 yards then the 240gr. Would 1k FPS with 300gr XTP's in 45 colt be sufficient. With 1k at the muzzle the calculator says it would be 905 at 100 yds with 545 FT LBs. Both 240 and 300gr bullets show a 9" drop at 100 with a 50yd zero.