Well, the way I see it they are both GREAT cartridges capable of taking anything on the face of the planet. Kind of like comparing the 270 with the 3006, you can split hairs on which one is better but they both cleanly harvest game. If I had to chose one again I would do what I did this time. See which one I could get cheaper. (PS, I acquired my SRH in 480 for 500)

Duane